As a homeowner, few things are as frustrating as opening a letter from your lender announcing that your monthly mortgage payment is going up-especially when you have a fixed-rate loan where the principal and interest shouldn’t change. If you’ve experienced this, you’re not alone. This surprise often stems from something called an escrow shortage.
At Mortgage Maestro Group, a veteran-owned, independent mortgage broker based in Denver, CO, we’ve helped countless clients navigate these unexpected adjustments. Led by Navy veteran Ray Williams (NMLS #216267) with over 20 years of experience since 2002, our team is dedicated to transparency and taking the stress out of mortgage solutions. In this post, we’ll break down what escrow shortages are, why they happen, how to handle them, and tips to stay ahead-drawing from real-world insights we share with our clients every day.
Watch our quick explanation from Ray Williams here:
What Is an Escrow Account?
When you have a mortgage, your monthly payment typically includes more than just principal and interest. Many loans require an escrow account (also called an impound account), where your lender collects a portion of your property taxes and homeowners insurance premiums each month. The lender holds these funds and pays the bills on your behalf when they’re due.
This setup provides peace of mind: You don’t have to worry about saving up for a large tax bill or forgetting an insurance renewal. It’s especially common with FHA loans, VA loans, and conventional loans requiring less than 20% down payment.
At closing, your lender estimates these costs based on current tax rates and insurance quotes, then divides them into 12 monthly payments. They also maintain a small cushion (usually 1-2 months’ worth) to avoid shortages.
Why Do Escrow Shortages Occur?
An escrow shortage happens when the money collected in your escrow account isn’t enough to cover the actual property tax or insurance bills. Your lender performs an annual escrow analysis (usually around your loan anniversary), reviewing past payments and projecting future costs. If there’s a deficit, they notify you.
Even with a fixed-rate mortgage, your total monthly payment can increase because the escrow portion adjusts to make up the difference and build a proper cushion for the coming year.
Common Causes of Escrow Shortages
Escrow shortages are more common than you might think, especially in today’s market. Here are the primary culprits:
- Rising Property Taxes: Property values have been increasing in many areas, including Colorado, California, Florida, Texas, and Wyoming (where we’re licensed). When your county reassesses your home, taxes often go up-sometimes significantly.
- Increasing Homeowners Insurance Premiums: Insurance costs have surged nationwide due to inflation, natural disasters, and rebuilding expenses. In high-risk areas for wildfires or hurricanes, premiums can jump dramatically from year to year.
- Initial Underestimation: At closing, estimates might be based on outdated information, leading to a shortfall in the first or second year.
- Changes in Coverage: Switching insurance providers, adding endorsements, or changes in flood insurance requirements can alter costs.
In 2025, many homeowners are seeing larger shortages due to these ongoing trends in taxes and insurance.
How an Escrow Shortage Impacts Your Payment
When your lender identifies a shortage:
- They calculate the deficit from the past year.
- They project higher costs for the next year.
- They adjust your monthly escrow payment upward to cover both.
This can add hundreds of dollars to your monthly payment temporarily. The good news? It’s not permanent-the adjustment ensures your account stays balanced moving forward.
Your Options for Handling an Escrow Shortage
You typically have two main choices when notified of a shortage:
- Pay the Shortage in a Lump Sum: Send a one-time payment to cover the deficit. This keeps your monthly escrow increase smaller (only accounting for future higher costs).
- Spread It Over 12 Months: The shortage gets added to your monthly payments, spreading the cost out. This is easier on cash flow but results in a larger monthly increase.
In some cases, if the shortage is small, lenders may allow other arrangements. Always review your escrow statement carefully and contact your servicer with questions.
Pro Tip: If you disagree with the analysis, you can request a review or provide updated insurance quotes/tax information.
Tips to Prevent or Minimize Future Escrow Shortages
While you can’t always control tax or insurance increases, you can take steps to soften the impact:
- Shop Your Homeowners Insurance Annually – Compare quotes to find better rates. Bundling with auto insurance or increasing your deductible (responsibly) can help.
- Monitor Property Tax Assessments – Check your county assessor’s website and appeal if you believe your home’s value is overstated.
- Consider Waiving Escrow (If Allowed) – Some conventional loans with 20%+ equity let you pay taxes and insurance directly. This gives more control but requires discipline to save for bills.
- Build Your Own Buffer – If possible, overpay your escrow slightly to create extra cushion.
- Stay Informed – Use tools like our Mortgage Calculator to estimate payments under different scenarios.
For investors using DSCR loans or those in unique situations (like self-employed or cannabis industry borrowers), we often structure loans to minimize escrow surprises.
How Mortgage Maestro Group Takes the Stress Out of Escrow Issues
As an independent, veteran-owned broker, we have access to multiple lenders, allowing us to find the best fit for your situation-including options that might minimize escrow requirements. Our “high tech and high touch” approach means clear communication every step of the way.
Whether you’re a first-time buyer, veteran qualifying for a VA loan with no down payment, investor with fix & flip projects, or someone consolidating debt through a cash-out refinance, we treat your mortgage like our own. Our 5-star Google reviews highlight our patience, expertise, and commitment to exceeding expectations.
We’ve helped clients in Denver and across Colorado, California, Florida, Wyoming, and Texas avoid pitfalls like escrow shortages through proactive education and personalized planning.
Ready to Review Your Mortgage Situation?
Don’t let an escrow shortage catch you off guard. Our team at Mortgage Maestro Group is here to review your current loan, explain your options, and help you plan for a stress-free future.
Call us today at 303-779-0591 or book your free consultation at https://mortgage-maestro.com/appointments/.
The dream of owning a home never gets old-and neither does our commitment to composing memories for our clients since 2002.
We put your bottom line first.
For more educational resources, check out:
¡Hablamos español! Visit https://mortgage-maestro.com/hablamos-espanol/ for Spanish-language support.
Key Points
- Escrow shortages occur when funds collected for taxes and insurance fall short, often causing payment increases even on fixed-rate loans.
- Primary causes include rising property taxes and homeowners insurance premiums.
- Homeowners can typically pay the shortage in a lump sum or spread it over 12 months.
- Proactive steps like shopping insurance and monitoring taxes can help minimize future shortages.
- Working with an experienced broker like Mortgage Maestro Group ensures transparency and personalized guidance.
Understanding Escrow Accounts in Depth
An escrow account acts as a neutral holding tank managed by your mortgage servicer. Federal guidelines (under RESPA) require lenders to conduct an annual analysis and limit the cushion to no more than two months’ worth of payments. This protects homeowners from over-collection while ensuring bills are paid on time.
In states like Colorado, property tax rates vary by county, and recent reassessments in growing areas like Denver have led to notable increases. Similarly, in Florida and Texas, insurance costs have spiked due to weather-related risks.
Detailed Causes and Real-World Examples
Consider a client we helped recently: A veteran in Colorado with a VA loan saw their insurance premium double due to wildfire risk updates. Their initial escrow estimate didn’t account for this jump, resulting in a $1,200 shortage. By reviewing their policy and finding a better rate, we reduced the impact significantly.
Another common scenario involves self-employed borrowers who’ve purchased investment properties. With DSCR loans, investors focus on rental income, but fluctuating local taxes can still create shortages if not monitored.
Escrow Analysis Process Explained
Each year, your servicer:
- Reviews actual disbursements (taxes/insurance paid).
- Projects next year’s costs (often conservatively high).
- Calculates any shortage or surplus.
- Sends a statement (by law, at least 30 days before any change).
If there’s a surplus over $50, they’re required to refund it.
Long-Term Strategies for Homeowners
Beyond immediate handling, consider these advanced tips:
- Use home equity for improvements that might qualify for tax deductions or lower insurance (e.g., storm-resistant upgrades).
- For veterans, VA loans often have flexible escrow options.
- Investors with multiple properties benefit from centralized tracking tools.
At Mortgage Maestro Group, we provide ongoing support post-closing-something big banks often lack. Our street fighter mentality means we advocate tenaciously for the best rates and terms across our wholesale lender network.
Market Insights for 2025
Current trends show insurance premiums rising 10-20% in many states we serve, while property values continue upward trajectories. This makes understanding escrow more important than ever for first-time buyers, veterans, and investors alike.
Whether you’re exploring Colorado home loans, VA loans in Texas, or self-employed mortgage options, our team demystifies the process with honesty and integrity.
